The official site of the Prime Minister’s Office
BETA
E-Petitions
- Petitions home
- View petitions
- Create a petition
- About e-petitions
- Step-by-Step Guide
- FAQs
- Terms and Conditions
- Privacy Policy
This petition is now closed, as its deadline has passed.
We the undersigned petition the Prime Minister to scrap the proposed introduction of ID cards. More details
Submitted by Paul Neath – Deadline to sign up by: 15 February 2007 – Signatures: 28,049
Petition update, 21 February 2007
The petition calling for the Government to abandon plans for a National ID Scheme attracted almost 28,000 signatures - one of the largest responses since this e-petition service was set up. So I thought I would reply personally to those who signed up, to explain why the Government believes National ID cards, and the National Identity Register needed to make them effective, will help make Britain a safer place.The petition disputes the idea that ID cards will help reduce crime or terrorism. While I certainly accept that ID cards will not prevent all terrorist outrages or crime, I believe they will make an important contribution to making our borders more secure, countering fraud, and tackling international crime and terrorism. More importantly, this is also what our security services - who have the task of protecting this country - believe.
So I would like to explain why I think it would be foolish to ignore the opportunity to use biometrics such as fingerprints to secure our identities. I would also like to discuss some of the claims about costs - particularly the way the cost of an ID card is often inflated by including in estimates the cost of a biometric passport which, it seems certain, all those who want to travel abroad will soon need.
In contrast to these exaggerated figures, the real benefits for our country and its citizens from ID cards and the National Identity Register, which will contain less information on individuals than the data collected by the average store card, should be delivered for a cost of around £3 a year over its ten-year life.
But first, it's important to set out why we need to do more to secure our identities and how I believe ID cards will help. We live in a world in which people, money and information are more mobile than ever before. Terrorists and international criminal gangs increasingly exploit this to move undetected across borders and to disappear within countries. Terrorists routinely use multiple identities - up to 50 at a time. Indeed this is an essential part of the way they operate and is specifically taught at Al-Qaeda training camps. One in four criminals also uses a false identity. ID cards which contain biometric recognition details and which are linked to a National Identity Register will make this much more difficult.
Secure identities will also help us counter the fast-growing problem of identity fraud. This already costs £1.7 billion annually. There is no doubt that building yourself a new and false identity is all too easy at the moment. Forging an ID card and matching biometric record will be much harder.
I also believe that the National Identity Register will help police bring those guilty of serious crimes to justice. They will be able, for example, to compare the fingerprints found at the scene of some 900,000 unsolved crimes against the information held on the register. Another benefit from biometric technology will be to improve the flow of information between countries on the identity of offenders.
The National Identity Register will also help improve protection for the vulnerable, enabling more effective and quicker checks on those seeking to work, for example, with children. It should make it much more difficult, as has happened tragically in the past, for people to slip through the net.
Proper identity management and ID cards also have an important role to play in preventing illegal immigration and illegal working. The effectiveness on the new biometric technology is, in fact, already being seen. In trials using this technology on visa applications at just nine overseas posts, our officials have already uncovered 1,400 people trying illegally to get back into the UK.
Nor is Britain alone in believing that biometrics offer a massive opportunity to secure our identities. Firms across the world are already using fingerprint or iris recognition for their staff. France, Italy and Spain are among other European countries already planning to add biometrics to their ID cards. Over 50 countries across the world are developing biometric passports, and all EU countries are proposing to include fingerprint biometrics on their passports. The introduction in 2006 of British e-passports incorporating facial image biometrics has meant that British passport holders can continue to visit the United States without a visa. What the National Identity Scheme does is take this opportunity to ensure we maximise the benefits to the UK.
These then are the ways I believe ID cards can help cut crime and terrorism. I recognise that these arguments will not convince those who oppose a National Identity Scheme on civil liberty grounds. They will, I hope, be reassured by the strict safeguards now in place on the data held on the register and the right for each individual to check it. But I hope it might make those who believe ID cards will be ineffective reconsider their opposition.
If national ID cards do help us counter crime and terrorism, it is, of course, the law-abiding majority who will benefit and whose own liberties will be protected. This helps explain why, according to the recent authoritative Social Attitudes survey, the majority of people favour compulsory ID cards.
I am also convinced that there will also be other positive benefits. A national ID card system, for example, will prevent the need, as now, to take a whole range of documents to establish our identity. Over time, they will also help improve access to services.
The petition also talks about cost. It is true that individuals will have to pay a fee to meet the cost of their ID card in the same way, for example, as they now do for their passports. But I simply don't recognise most claims of the cost of ID cards. In many cases, these estimates deliberately exaggerate the cost of ID cards by adding in the cost of biometric passports. This is both unfair and inaccurate.
As I have said, it is clear that if we want to travel abroad, we will soon have no choice but to have a biometric passport. We estimate that the cost of biometric passports will account for 70% of the cost of the combined passports/id cards. The additional cost of the ID cards is expected to be less than £30 or £3 a year for their 10-year lifespan. Our aim is to ensure we also make the most of the benefits these biometric advances bring within our borders and in our everyday lives.
Yours sincerely,
Tony Blair
More information: http://www.pm.gov.uk/output/Page10960.asp
More details from petition creator
The introduction of ID cards will not prevent terrorism or crime, as is claimed. It will be yet another indirect tax on all law-abiding citizens of the UK.
Current signatories
Because there are so many signatories, only the most recent 500 are shown on this page.
- G Kais
- Paul Gilbody
- Jan Bros
- Pamela Skilton
- Nathan Thompson
- Jo Rider
- Jeremy Higgs
- Elizabeth Critchley
- Cairns McDevitte
- Alun Thompson
- Martin Vince
- Chris Streets
- Stuart Baker
- Dave Cuttle
- Mike Ramsey
- Andrew Jones
- DARREN WARE
- L. Rigby
- David Stanford
- Avril Gladwin
- Shahida H
- J Fowler
- M.P. Atwill
- Christine Clemo
- Andrew Cole
- Sarah Hyde
- Adrian Holme
- richard.jackson
- J Rutkowski
- Mark Rowland
- Kenneth Speakman
- keith brooks
- Amanda Fraser
- Carl Booth
- Rosanne Macmillan
- Heather Holberry
- David John Bates
- Sam Shin
- April Colclough
- Diane Skerm
- Ross Daines
- Nicholas Colclough
- I dont want to be identified
- Sara Foster
- Terence Eglinton
- Anne Lowe
- Vicki Brown
- martin jackson
- David Stolworthy
- Karl Horton
- Lucy Meyler
- Colin Ridley
- Caroline Stevens
- Keith Burton
- Elizabeth Hunter
- Cynthia Lewis
- sylvia jarvis
- Emily Erskine
- Mike Doubleday
- David Gerring
- Dennis Anderson
- Rosemarie Blanshard
- john oliver
- Deborah Clark
- mick mee
- Simon Preece
- Peter Keeble
- John Wellings
- Robert Pragnell
- GRANT HOWARTH
- Howard Batey
- A.Mason
- Tim Fosker
- louisa ward
- Bridget Whell
- Paul Sweeney
- j boothby
- Frankie Lampl
- Ruth Brown
- Joy Nottingham
- J.CLOW
- John Nottingham
- Alan Noon
- David Nottingham
- Craig Finnerty
- Genevieve Powell
- Hazel Corser
- Andrew Leech
- Masha Bolton
- tom wiseman
- Anthony Davies
- John Robinson
- Heather Pritchard
- Alan Waldron
- Joanna Hockley
- Mr P McAneny
- David Kerry
- Harry Garland
- Barry Gee
- Guy Levy
- Lee Malyon
- Keith Ballard
- Mr R. Harrison
- Nicola Harding
- Umran Aziz
- Blythe Pepino
- Andrew Harris
- Nina Wehling
- Parvez Anwar
- Gemma Langdon
- KAREN CRANSTON
- seb miller
- David Pugh
- anthony hill
- Kate Barber
- Brett Richardson
- Sue Heathcote
- Grace Shortland
- Joe Merrell
- Ann Wellman
- John Packham
- David Foulkes
- Nicholas Brain
- vicky forbes
- Andy Ridout
- paul sibley
- Sarah Clarke
- jo adams
- ann sibley
- Nina Pratley
- Elizabeth Evans
- C A Goddard
- Malcolm Bennett
- Juliet Whitley
- Frank Markham
- Richard Lander
- Harry James
- Andrea Greenwood
- paul foyster
- Ben Ahmady
- Tim Carroll
- Tracey Newberry
- Mark Ledger
- Steven Pollard
- Lindsay Cherryholme
- Chris Ford
- eric williams
- Mike Parsons
- Nigel Spivey
- Stuart Barnley
- Jacob Spencer
- Alice Forster
- John Glanville
- Neil Faith
- Steve
- Vic Stuthridge
- Jon Watson
- Vicky Noakes
- kevin leonard
- Colin Trott
- Lewis Mason
- Seimon Powell
- Ron Mole
- Roy Shephard
- Graeme Wallace
- Dane Koekoek
- Stephen Slatter
- graham delahunt
- Ben Doon
- Graham Tayler
- Matthew Pennock
- Dean Overton
- Andrew Livingstone
- Katherine Aethurs
- Derek Brangwyn
- Rosemary Unwin
- David Wood
- Gwen Funnell
- Shirley Hartup
- ALAN BRADBURY
- Anita Bramley
- Sandra Webb
- Christine Cambridge
- Marian Hellen
- Richard May
- Peter Edwards
- Christopher S. Arridge
- Adrian Falck
- janet white
- Mahew Page
- Trev Walker
- Chamali Fernando
- Brian Barttelot
- haydn redding
- Conrado Rivera
- Hannah Furneaux-Gotch
- Ted Bell
- Mr & Mrs M S Heslop Q.C.
- christopher pennington
- Frank Daniels
- Kathryn Price
- Martin Gould
- Adrian Watts
- prashant dudyala
- Carly Jeffrey
- david stuart
- Andrew Hepburn
- Andrew Ormerod
- Richard Lamb
- S vdH
- John Spink
- claire cittern
- Laura Edson
- l phillips
- Karl John Reynolds
- Daniel Gray
- john browb
- John Angell
- Ron Farrington
- Lorna Angell
- David Reilly
- Jonathan Storrs-Fox
- George Petrouis
- deborah manzoori
- Belinda Brenner
- Michael Harrison
- Melita dennett
- Ian Dempster
- John Tilbury
- Mal Colman
- Guy Gisborne
- Michael King
- Simon Dalley
- Paul Frew
- S Kanji
- Stuart Sheridan
- Derek Willows
- Dave Farrington
- Philip Dunn
- Martin Green
- Andy Rose
- Huw Kyffin
- matthew ryder
- Pauline Roper
- lynda cowan
- nouri Taghani
- al
- Jesse Denwood
- Hugh Herten
- Peter Mason
- lavinia archer
- Constanza Tolman-Lopez
- N Joy
- Damien Ransome
- Richard Fieldhouse
- Samantha Jones
- john stubbs
- Gillian Davison
- S Hyde
- roger denham
- Alex Rousseau
- Suzanne Milne
- George Orwell
- Kevin Harris
- Peggy Doubleday
- Robert Fraser
- Gemma Stephenson
- g aBBAS
- Martin Hugh Fraser
- c madden
- Ralph Jones
- Avril Brackpool
- Malcolm Robertson
- Willard Foxton
- Paul Smith
- anthony ward
- Aaron Lane
- Alfred Quinton
- amardeep mudhan
- Carole Quinton
- w tinkler
- Phillip Kimpton
- S.Jones
- michelle
- Lee Wilson
- Chris Ramsey
- Chris Hurst
- megan brydie
- rachel turpin
- Darrel Wright
- Phillip Jones
- Matthew Tonge
- Rosa Hardt
- Rex Palmer
- Robert Bushell
- Philip Willmer
- michael moore
- Jonathan Somerville
- Alan Skinner
- tom McManamon
- John Hurst
- alec wood
- Audrey Graham
- Marion Healy
- David Austin
- Richard Allen
- Victoria
- fiona meaney
- Frederic Stansfield
- Rex Parker
- Tanya Webber
- Don Neilson
- david macDonald
- MICHAEL J PHILLIPS
- John Trezise
- Andrew Wilson
- dave may
- simon cass
- Danny Inga
- mark aylward
- Dave Biddle
- Nicholas H L Freeman
- P heymoz
- Steven Rosenwould
- Tim Blythman
- craig bradley
- Alastair Webber
- lucy swift
- Stacey Go
- Naomi Ocean
- Mark Heppell
- Alison Terry
- joan miller
- David Cooper
- Sarah Jackson
- andrew margarson
- Greg Corke
- John J Kay
- Colin Neill Wrigley
- Penny Sutton
- Brian Remmer
- m.c.frankland
- Helen McNamara
- peter john dixon
- Colin Brookes
- Rufus Sweetman
- emma cox
- keith v bladen
- Caroline Emma Willson
- Chris Powell
- Ian Hall
- Tamara Hackett
- M Southern
- Theresa Bartliff
- James Lemon
- Kai En Ong
- James Coslett
- j holt
- Derek Benstead
- john bryson
- Dan Sparks
- Morley Donkin
- Ian Garland
- Heidi Burrows
- Ian Horrocks
- paul snow
- Joshua Wiskey
- Jenny Hill
- M Coles
- John Carter
- Patricia Carter
- Josh
- Peter Mandlesson
- andy jackson
- Bridget Bernadette Phythian
- Sally Jones
- Jan M Carter
- Felicty McLean
- Christopher Davies
- Jamiesha Majevadia
- Bob Clapperton
- Mike Kamp
- Ian E Winkle
- Sheryl Chudley
- Ivan Link
- Liz Ayre
- Mrs D Voigt
- ceri Gibbons
- John Frone
- Sue Templar
- Roger Brown
- b. mansell
- Hugh Clarke
- Helen Reeves
- Stephen Smith
- Daniel Bold
- John Mcgreal
- Barry Edwards
- Patrick McDonald
- Muiz Anwar
- keith lewis
- noel brown
- Eddie McDowell
- Sunrise Lovatt
- Derek Petrie
- Michael Chambers
- Matthew Baildon
- jasmine chowdhury
- Sadia Sajid
- Mark Beards
- Ambreen
- Aylif Kingston
- Dan Pryce
- Matthew Tobias Cole
- Lynn Ingleton
- Leigh Hughes
- Mrs D Benton
- Rosemary Roach
- John Ginger
- DEREK WATKINSON
- Naadia Rahman
- farah
- Gary Kelly
- Phil Statham
- Beverley McCormick
- Jeremy Cuthbert
- noor alramadhani
- Sharmina Begum
- Mohikul Islam
- Alan Gardner
- m mitchell
- Paul Hattersley
- K. Omond
- abdul s ghafoor
- Ken Warren
- Anthony Jackman
- Amanda Dixon
- Dawn Lomax
- Merina Khanom
- matt grubb
- Mike Brundell
- kelly fellows
- Rohana
- Joanna Haywood
- Gareth`
- zoe westmancoat
- fateha
- Ashley Leaney
- sanaa ramzan
- Ann Ellis
- Kevin Donnellon
- Angie Leach
- Ryszard Jerzy Bak
- Muhammad Jaidin
- Ali Alhadithi
- Peter Oliver
- Marcia Pires
- Ursula Cox
- David Clancy
- Michael Tomkins
- Louise Arnold
- Eugene Conlon
- sue nightingale
- Rhiannon Roberts
- faheem shakur
- simon ben
- Rod Cox
- M Hamid
- Edward J Moses
- Tim Jones
- Maddy Bunker
- Duncan Moore
- Catherine Mooney
- John Cuthbert
- Michelle North
- Samreena Haq
- Antony Paddle
- michael crockett
- Mike Elder
- Dr Paul Bell
- Roger Higgins
- sarah milton
- Jeannette Barr
- Jamie Wiltshire
- Andy Gibson
- L. Thompson
- keith goodwin
- Tom Ferguson
- Ann Griffiths
- simon boyle
- Nicholas Amato
- dawn davis
- Mr A Pretzel
- Roger Sanford
- Caroline Stuart
- Anna Rose
- kayleigh roberts
- andrew pennington
- Rana
- Usman Ali
Because there are so many signatories, only the most recent 500 are shown on this page.
